Navigation auf uzh.ch
Navigation auf uzh.ch
The sociology of elites has long considered families as the unit of analysis in studies of power dynamics between elite dynasties and their transmission of wealth and prestige over generations. However, the assumption that families are cohesive units with common goals and agendas does not hold, especially for large and powerful family dynasties. Internal conflicts and clan rivalries throughout history suggest that independent clans, rather than families, are the more appropriate level for aggregation. The increasing availability of large-scale genealogical datasets and advances in social network analysis allow this more fine-grained perspective to be implemented even without historical documentation on observed clan structures. Niccolò Armandola's paper builds on socio-anthropological conceptualizations of kinship and on hierarchical clustering techniques to present a new method for identifying independent clans within families that relies only on network-dependent terms. I use simulated data and an empirical kinship network of families of early modern Basel, Switzerland to compare a clan detector algorithm’s performance with common community detection techniques. The historical accuracy of the clan structures detected is further assessed with various status indicators. The analyses show that the proposed clan detector algorithm is more suitable for identifying historically accurate clans than the traditional approaches. The application of the new method to the kinship network of Basel families sheds light on the city’s stratification into high- and low-status societies in which elite families were also divided into privileged and less privileged clans.
Facebook LinkedIn
